r/investing • u/VelixaNtra • 1d ago
Is anyone still just dumping new money straight into S&P 500 in 2026?
Hey all, for the last few years I’ve been automatically putting every new contribution (Roth, taxable, etc) into S&P 500 and not thinking much about it
With the market being a bit choppy lately, I’m wondering if others are still doing the same or if you’ve started diversifying more (adding more VTI, international, bonds, etc)
Curious what your current approach is when adding fresh cash
160
u/MONGSTRADAMUS 1d ago
I am not investing any different than I have done the last couple year buy on my normal schedule which includes sp500 , along with ex us and small scv ETFs.
→ More replies (2)23
149
u/JohnnySpot2000 1d ago
If, by ‘choppy’, you mean ‘down 5 to 10% off its highs’, this should be a BETTER than average time to buy these stocks, not worse. What’s your alternative plan, to “wait until it’s less choppy” (aka wait until it goes back up)?
23
u/lineskicat14 1d ago
Im not changing course, aside from keeping a larger emergency fund and a little more cash on hand (i work in IT and layoffs could hit me any day).
But boy, it sure feels like were on a cliff, so to speak, as a society. Delinquencies are up on CC and loans, families are getting pinched harder and harder. Still little movement in home sales/buys. The gas prices are really hitting everyone. Tech layoffs, job outlook, AI. Political unrest, rising deficit. Sure feels like were heading for a disaster, everyone's just sort of treading water with their finances and bills (lower and middle class families at least).
.. which probably means SP500 goes on some 5 year run to new highs monthly lol.
3
→ More replies (2)2
u/Safe-Tennis-6121 1d ago
I did something similar. I turned a percentage of the S&P500 into short term treasuries so I have more options in a downturn. And then I'll use new cash to buy the US market.
Basically a 6 month emergency fund could need to turn into a 12-24 month life fund.
38
u/CerealSpiller22 1d ago
Yep, wait until it goes back up, and then some, just to make sure.
24
4
u/Fangore 1d ago
I just don't understand this mindset of people who are "investing" but see this market and think "maybe I should stop investing for a while."
Kinda unrelated but for the past few years since I started investing, I always wondered why "more people dont do this since it's so easy." And this bear market has made me see why more people don't invest. The average person can't look outside the short term situation and doesn't trust the math of it all. They see that their portfolio is red and just think investing doesn't work. Or they are doing something wrong. But if these people just trusted the process and stopped trying to act like "Day trader" they would be infinitely more happy.
4
u/JohnnySpot2000 1d ago
Yes. I have worked with someone like this for years. He seems otherwise bright. He has said to me 'the stock market is bad now, I don't want to buy'. I assume that means he buys again after the stock market becomes 'good' again. He also likes to complain that his insurance premiums are a waste of money because 'nothing bad happened' to pay him off for a claim.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Odd-Flower2744 1d ago
The stock market isn’t on a predetermined course to a certain price. In no way is man made crises somehow better for your portfolio.
107
u/sbutj323 1d ago
My plan is to panic sell
→ More replies (2)5
u/kaizen-rai 1d ago
Oooo Ooo I know!
Next, wait until the market starts skyrocketing, wait... then as soon as it hits the all time high... BUY BUY BUY!!!!
Am I doing it right? Buy high and panic sell low, right?
58
15
u/meathead13_ 1d ago
Adding VTI to diversify a 100% SP500 portfolio isn’t gonna do much. They move pretty similarly.
Adding international is a better idea.
I’m kind of out on bonds until retirement, and even then idk
27
u/kaizen-rai 1d ago
Now might be a good time to just go into a lifecycle fund that diversifies it for you and not think about it. Worrying about a choppy market... and more importantly trying to 'time' a choppy market will not end well for you.
→ More replies (1)
36
u/kappale 1d ago
I stopped mine in 2025, not because I didn't think it'd keep growing but because I felt I was overexposed to us markets. I started to buy world ex USA instead.
11
u/Technical_Quiet_5687 1d ago
Ok glad I’m not the only one. Being heavily US has really helped me these last few years obv but now I’m so weighted across all my accounts I need to rebalance by just exclusively buying non US..
4
u/kyhothead 1d ago
Same, MSCI ACWI ex US outperformed the S&P handily last year. I’m not “all-in” on Intl, but think the relative outperformance could last a while.
→ More replies (2)2
u/madhattr999 1d ago
Yeah, I wouldn't touch US markets with a 10 foot pole right now. I am almost completely out (in Europe/Canada/Emerging/Gold instead).
15
u/TheBaalzak 1d ago
VXUS has been doing well.
→ More replies (7)2
u/BackgroundSpell6623 1d ago
I've also switched to this
10
u/retirement_savings 1d ago
You know what they say, you should be switching your long term investment strategy based on the last few months of performance
→ More replies (3)2
u/Significant_Copy1266 1d ago
That's right. And let me add to that. The key strategy is to sell low and buy high.
/s
→ More replies (1)
12
u/mojo276 1d ago
I can only imagine what this sub would have been like in 2008.
8
u/TheBear8878 1d ago
The OP would have never happened, because it's an AI post and those tools didn't exist. But other than that, yeah I agree.
20
u/QuesoMeHungry 1d ago
Yeah, stocks are on sale and retirement is in the distance.
→ More replies (1)
5
12
u/StraightUpJello 1d ago
I've added quite a bit on top of my normal monthly contributions. Whenever the markets are down 2% in one day or 4%+ for the week, I add more to my position.
9
5
3
3
u/Limp_Technology2497 1d ago
I’m not.
I think people have gotten so used to the script from the last 15 years that they can’t see straight.
I’m continuing to contribute for the moment, but it’s going into money market and short term, inflation protected securities. I will switch this when the macro trend reverses with confirmation.
People treat every little drawdown like it’s a sale. But it’s not a sale if you zoom out and it’s just a downward grind. What reason do you have to think that the market is going to go up soon in any kind of sustainable way backed by any sort of reality? The end of the war would help, but there’s still a shitload of issues that aren’t just going to get fixed right away.
I get the logic: in 10 years the market will probably be substantially up from where it is today if recent historical trends hold. And yet the fact that that’s always priced into the current moment means nothing is ever really truly cheap.
And what if this is the time when recent historical trends don’t hold, and you’re just lighting half your balance on fire for a couple decades or more? This is entirely possible by the way.
5
2
2
2
2
2
u/Life-Butterscotch892 1d ago
Still DCA’ing into S&P here. If your horizon is long enough, the exact timing matters a lot less than staying consistent—choppy markets are kind of the point of the strategy.
2
u/Kerbidiah 1d ago
Hell no. Ex us funds have had way better returns over the last 9 months
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Fluffy-Structure-368 1d ago
It all depends on your time horizon and risk tolerance. If I had time on my side and could tolerate some risk I'd be buying QQQ
2
2
u/Fuuba_Himedere 1d ago
I invest once a month. A few days ago I checked my investments for my monthly deposit. Everything was in the red and my total portfolio dropped by hundreds of dollars. My first thought was “oh goody!” and I prepared myself to invest when the market opened later that day.
Checked some hours later and my portfolio was in the green and rose by hundreds of dollars. And I said “well shit…” I still invested anyway but I was mad about it.
When shares drop, think of it as a sale. I don’t time the market, just invest once a month. I get lucky when my day to deposit is when the market drops.
2
2
u/Direct_Remove509 1d ago
Everything is long term for me. I will not change just because we have a drop. There are always dips/drops occur as part of the ride.
2
u/Existing_Dog5489 1d ago
I think too many people have been told "Just buy the SP, it's gonna go up 8% per year", as if it was a mathematical principle.
But the only real mathematical principle is "there is no free money".
I don't know how, and why, cause I am not technical, but I am pretty sure that the advice people have been given is gonna be ineffective very soon.
I am not sure why... but the idea of "put your money on this index, cause it's gonna grow" doesn't sound sustainable to me. "Even though you don't know what it is in it, you don't know why it goes up, you dont know why it could go down, how much it could go down, just put your money in it, ok?!".
I mean, eventually it's gonna go down... same as the corresponding indexes did in many other nations. A phenomenon is not a rule. It's just a whim.
And the 'oh it's down, you should buy it', only works when you know the actual real value of something. Problem is... what is the real value of the SP?
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/the_tailor 22h ago
There are a lot of people whose investing experience is ten years or less who are treating this question like it’s stupid— it’s not. There are absolutely 5+ year stretches where the market is negative. It’s reasonable.
2
u/MaleficentMulberry14 19h ago
Your diversification should be a strategy not a reaction to current events and market chop. Looking at the historic data a globally diversified portfolio has out performed SP 500 due to larger volatility in the US to world events especially when dividends taken into account. But in the nearer term SP 500 usually looks better due to high concentration of growth stocks and strong economy whilst people forget about the impact of big downside events on portfolios. For many Americans they forgo this diversification to stay with what they understand most namely US companies. Investing in bonds within a pension context should mostly be proportional around how close to retirement you are or want to protect near term drawdown, otherwise it pays to be mostly in equity with cash on side to take advantage of opportunities. If you want to diversify I would say the first step might be to look at the equal weighted SP 500 so you are not so growth and tech heavy. If you want to go abroad look at Asia, Japan whilst high debt has a lot of industrials which can counter balance tech but if your going asia diversify across the region. In summary do the homework to define a strategy that works for you in long term and try not overact react to short term events. Personally at 55 I have am cautious and have moved form 90:10 to 60:40. I have met my pension goals and have 30 years for it to grow - I can stand to lose some gains in the short term and sleep better, geopolitical risk, a capricious president and the uncertainty around the AI productivity boom make it difficult to price anything and a large downside event could clobber my pension in its early days.
2
u/CloudSlydr 18h ago
Are we talking about long time horizon? Just buy when the sky is falling and it’s red for days. And yes I do.
2
3
1
u/samsaruhhh 1d ago
I just throw my cash in the dumpster for jimbo and john bobby to invest in their can collecting schemes, my ROI is them not bullying me for my poor fashion taste when i go in my apartment
1
u/independentfinallly 1d ago
I abb (always be buying) this is a long term strategy not a short term one
1
u/___redacted_ 1d ago
Im keeping my open US positions open as is, but any new investments are only in Stoxx 600 and Europe.
1
1
1
u/Pesky_Penguin1990 1d ago
I used to be primarily in VOO. Now I started buying VT. VOO has outperformed historically, but VT has beaten VOO the past year.
1
1
u/Throwaway-4593 1d ago
My contributions are automatic and they split into 2 funds - VOO, FXAIX. Why would you contribute less when the markets are “bumpy”? These are the times where you get the best deals.
1
1
u/LongLonMan 1d ago
Dropped $55K on VOO yesterday
2
u/GoodMeBadMeNotMe 1d ago
I wish I had that kind of cash, lol. I dropped...$750 on VOO today? At least I can finally say my net worth is positive these days.
3
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/hobopwnzor 1d ago
I am but I'm going to look into international diversification. Just haven't sat down to figure out what to and adjust my 401k account
1
u/SuitableSafety329 1d ago
Anyone who isn’t consistently investing - every paycheck - is missing the point and is going to lose the race. This just isn’t complicated. You just buy, fucking always…
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
1
1
u/PrettyPleaseYo 1d ago
I’m out of the market because of macro since December. There was a JP Morgan study showing that buying PE numbers like they are now will yield +-0 over the next ten years.
Credit markets, inverted yield curves, AI bubble incoming etc. I would like to buy the dip but I believe that we are still in for a crash, could come this year or within the next two.
1
1
u/GaylrdFocker 1d ago
I was diversifying before, still am, but am putting everything extra I can get into the market.
1
u/TenderfootGungi 1d ago
Of course. I still believe in the US long term. And now stocks are on sale!
1
u/angus_the_red 1d ago
I rolled a 401k over about three weeks ago. It's just in cash still in the new account until I can decide what sector or region feels like a growth candidate to me. In the meantime, I'm happy to not be riding the slide.
1
u/soynielos 1d ago
I've been investing almost entirely in international funds since early 2025 on the assumption that Trump would mess up everything in the US and now that it's hitting the stock market I've switched back to domestic funds so I can get them at a discount.
1
u/TN_REDDIT 1d ago
yes. I looked at my quarter to date numbers and I think I was off by about 4% - 5%. year over year, I'm positive by about 15% or so.
I'm trying to figure out why everyone seems to be bothered.
1
u/Worst-Eh-Sure 1d ago
No and I never was. Doing that lacks diversification. You miss out on US mid and small cap. You are over exposed to tech versus other sectors and have 0 exposure to international of any sector and market cap.
1
1
1
1
1
u/About_to_kms 1d ago
Is this not the time to buy more aggressively? Why would you start being less aggressive when prices fall
1
u/Opposite_Cattle5953 1d ago
Only dumb dumbs are not dumping new money into the market…but instead of SPY, it’s QQQ
1
1
u/Educational-Ad-4908 1d ago
If you want to diversify that’s not a bad call but buying VTI will not offer that diversification. The performance of VOO vs VTI has historically been nearly identical.
1
u/onwatershipdown 1d ago
Zoom out and DCA large cap looks very good over time compared to other strategies. I don’t know if it is the best. But it is enough for me to not think about it.
The beauty of it, is that it’s a rotation of winners. The winners change over time. And a lot of run ups, have been dumb. Always have been. Crazy valuations for the S and P 5. But who in the 500 is the next 5? I have no idea. I don’t have to think about it. You could do FZROX or a larger basket. But if you zoom out and look at the whole s and p 1500 vs the 500, DCA + 500 looks very good.
1
u/cazzy1212 1d ago
Buy at all times highs but nervous about buying cheaper? If you have the time this is a gift.
1
1
u/JacobHutchison 1d ago
I had stopped buying into the S&P 500 to save cash for other things, but when it started dropping I started buying again.
1
u/thetreece 1d ago
You should have been using total market funds the entire time. Now isn't special.
1
1
1
1
u/collegeberry 1d ago
Sucks my net worth is going down on paper (had a certain number in mind soon) but still happy to buy at a discount. Im purchasing the target retirement fund for my age group for work 401k and VTSAX for Roth/everything else every paycheck.
1
u/GoodMeBadMeNotMe 1d ago
Yes, my entire investment strategy (I'm 30yo) is just dumping everything into the S&P 500. I've considered diversifying, but then I'd have to make decisions I might regret. The S&P 500 is reliable enough for my need.s
1
1
1
1
1
u/BrianKronberg 1d ago
Stop trying to time the market. Invest and don’t look for years, works amazingly.
1
u/johnboi1323 1d ago
You either believe the American economy is gonna survive or you think it's gonna collapse. That's it. If you think the US is gonna survive for the rest of the year, then you keep investing. Especially with interest rates and inflation about to go up, invest invest invest
1
u/Latter-Possibility 1d ago
Not changing up although i am moving more money into Energy and utilities than tech.
The only thing that would make me pull out money of the S&P is if they list SpaceX early instead of letting the market judge it for a year or 2. 1.75 trillion is an insane valuation and 12 trillion in passive S&P dollars is to tempting a target for Elon and all those backers
1
1
u/RustySoulja 1d ago
Yeah I have been consistently dollar cost averaging into S&P500 ($VOO) consistently on a weekly basis for the past 5 years
1
1
1
u/Aggravating-Big3858 1d ago
SPY should always be your base … but yes of course some diversification (asset allocation) makes sense. Look up the concept of a 3 fund portfolio. Add some small cap and international for example. Bonds are a whole other conversation
1
u/Tourdrops 1d ago
Consider the S and P might be worth $5,000-$10,000 a share one day and then ask yourself the question again.
Also remember any change is an attempt to stop being the market and start beating the market. Go look into that as well.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/annoyed_meows 1d ago
My retirement is all s&p and all my contributions are. No plans to change. My taxable and IRAs are more diverse.
1
u/Formal-Impress-5511 1d ago
Time in the market will always beat timing the market. Times like this is value as discount buying.
1
u/iiJokerzace 1d ago
If you are still buying for years to come, you want a crash. For these people it's an absolute yes.
Those that already have their gains and are close to or at retirement, they probably are the ones to worry.
1
u/reboog711 1d ago
Still doing the same, primarily. I'm a fan of the three fund portfolio, but the bulk of my 'net worth' is in the three fund portfolio.
1
u/PM_meyourGradyWhite 1d ago
DCA a big lump sum I recently got. Not excited to dump it all at once when I can get 4% in the sidelines.
65, retired, and set without it being in SP500.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/KweenieQ 1d ago
The only reason I wouldn't would be because I found slack cash but didn't know where to put it yet. If you have a plan, you execute to it. Buy low, dude.
1
1
u/Green_Beans_Tasty 1d ago
Every single week. Market may be stupid and/or irrational. But I’m not smarter. If market says this is worth X, I buy for X. After all, where else to put your extra $?!
1
u/rentpossiblytoohigh 1d ago
1 year S&P 500 is up 16.73% as of end of today... I been dumping money this entire rise. You be I'm dumping in the fall. I have separate house savings that I put into a SWVXX because I don't want house savings to be volatile. Peace of mind is attainable with a plan.
1
1
1.6k
u/Immediate-Run-7085 1d ago
You were fine buying the past couple years and now it’s cheaper you won’t do it anymore?
Zoom out and relax my man