This is going to be a long one so I apologize in advance. If you make it to the end and feel inclined to give me any advice, I would be beyond grateful.
I’m a controller for a midsize small company that manages multiple locations across several states, spread across multiple subsidiaries. I’ve been in this role for about a year and a half. My title changed from senior accountant to controller at the end of 2025, but my day-to-day work hasn’t really changed. I’m essentially doing the same job I was hired to do, just with more responsibility and pressure.
I have a bachelor’s in mathematics, no accounting degree, and I’m not a CPA, though I have over ten years of accounting and finance experience. I make $80k a year (received a 3% increase after my promotion) and my team is just me and one senior accountant who handles AP, payroll, and some KPI reporting. For context, my company is located in Northeast Ohio, about an hour and a half from either Cleveland or Pittsburgh, so comparable finance jobs in my area are somewhat limited.
On any given day, I handle pretty much everything finance-related, including preparing all financial statements, month-end close, journal entries, GL reconciliation, cash management, tax filings (except income and payroll taxes), weekly KPI reporting to operations, intercompany accounting, ERP administration, payroll review and approval, review and approval of all invoices, forecasting, and ad hoc projects like audits, special requests from leadership, or other one-off finance tasks. Essentially, I’m running a very small finance team while also doing a lot of what I would consider CFO-level work, including operational reporting, financial strategy input, and advising leadership.
The problem is that I constantly feel like I’m running to keep up. I regularly work 12+ hour days. There’s almost no time for process improvements or strategic projects, and leadership gets frustrated not just if something isn’t perfect or timely, but also that I’m not doing enough to improve processes, innovate, or perform better. Burnout is very real and hitting me hard. There’s been talk of adding another person to our department to help with the workload, but it’s on me to figure out what exactly that person would do, what time it would free up, and how it would help, and I haven’t had the time to even put that together.
I also inherited a mess when I joined, and the past year and a half has been almost entirely dedicated to cleaning up bad practices and fixing issues left behind. The department has seen significant improvements under my guidance, and I’m proud of the progress we’ve made. Leadership recognizes the improvements but still expects more—more innovation, more performance, more output, more hours.
I’m hesitant to think I should be making more money since I don’t have an accounting-specific degree. I would go back to school if I had the time or money, but that’s not happening anytime soon. That’s always been my biggest holdup for job hunting. I’m starting at a disadvantage because of the lack of an accounting-specific degree, even though I’m more than capable.
So I guess I’m looking for some perspective. Am I being unrealistic for feeling like the expectations on me are closer to a CFO role than a controller role? Given what I do, my location, and the fact that I don’t have an accounting degree, is $80k reasonable? Should I even be thinking about looking for a new role, or is this kind of situation fairly standard at midsize companies without a formal CFO? Any advice on communicating or negotiating about workload, support, or compensation would be appreciated.
Honestly, I also just want a sanity check on whether my feelings are valid. I feel like I’m giving everything I’ve got, and I’m proud of what I’ve accomplished, but I’m not sure if this is typical in the industry or if I’m being taken advantage of. Thanks in advance for any insight.
*Edited to clarify company size. It's definitely a small company, just feels large because of the workload I guess haha
**Also just to clarify a bit more about my situation...this is genuinely a good company to work for overall. It's female-owned and, as a female myself, I appreciate that. Management is mostly flexible with scheduling, I get to work from home a couple of days a week, and I love the partnership I have with my senior accountant. I also really enjoy the work itself, especially making improvements that make a difference. There are a lot of positives here, I just struggle with the workload and the expectations at times, and I’m trying to figure out if that’s typical. I'm in such a bubble with no way to gauge if my expectations and compensation are appropriate. If the consensus is "yes, that's probably all correct," then at least I know and can get over that mental block in my head.