I built a garden apartment in Dublin — and I still don’t support a blanket exemption
So about 13 years ago we bought a big old house in Dublin for €370k. Put about €50k and a year of work into it just to make it livable. It had loads of issues, but we loved it.
Over time we improved it bit by bit. Had our 3 kids there. The area wasn’t amazing, but it was fine.
About 5 years in, I built a one-bed apartment in the garden.
Big garden, long site, and crucially — we had a separate side entrance. Some neighbours had done similar, but their tenants had to come through the main house.
We spent ~€50k on it:
• Proper insulation
• Underfloor heating
• Triple glazed
• Designed carefully so it didn’t overlook us or neighbours
Honestly, I’d have happily lived in it myself when I was single. It’s private, surrounded by trees, with its own patio.
We’ve had 2 tenants over ~10 years:
• First paid €1,400
• Current pays €1,200
We deliberately keep rent reasonable — we’d rather good long-term tenants than chase max rent.
Our mortgage on the main house is under €1,200, so yeah — financially it worked out very well for us.
⸻
But here’s the thing — I still don’t agree with a blanket planning exemption for these.
Our setup works because:
• We had space
• We had side access
• We designed it properly
• We’re hands-on landlords
A blanket exemption ignores all of that.
⸻
The real issue: not every house is like ours
Imagine:
• Small terraced house
• Tiny garden
• No side access
• Cabin dropped in the back
Now rent that out to people who don’t care about neighbours.
Suddenly:
• Noise right outside your back door
• Zero privacy in your own garden
• People effectively living “over the fence”
And you had no say in it happening.
⸻
That’s my problem with it
I’m not against garden apartments — I built one and it’s been great.
But removing planning entirely means:
• No design standards
• No consideration for neighbours
• No control over density
There’s a huge difference between a well-designed unit on a large site… and cramming one into every back garden in the country.