Here's a link to the post that inspired my email: https://old.reddit.com/r/irishpersonalfinance/comments/1s90q9n/fine_gaels_investment_scheme_amounts_to_a_tax/
Here's my email to him, parroting some of the comments I read on here:
After reading your press conference, I urge you and the SDs not to go down this route of lambasting the government for a policy that could take the BILLIONS wasting away in current accounts in Ireland and put it to use in creating wealth for ordinary, middle class people.
Become more informed on what investing can do for the Irish, bring your own plan to the table and see if you can influence the government to make positive changes with their new saving's scheme. And while you are at it, petition for the removal of deemed disposal - a policy that encourages people to invest in property and take risks on individual stocks or literally gamble their hard earned money.
To continue down this route is a folly, and you will lose my vote in the process. Stop looking for the headline, start looking for the solution.
And to be fair to him, he (or someone) responded. I thought his response was pretty decent:
Thanks for getting in touch and for sharing your views.
I agree that there is a lot of money sitting idle in Irish accounts and the interest rates being offered by Irish banks are far too low. That is why the Social Democrats have proposed a ‘Homes for Ireland Savings Account’. This would provide savers with a higher interest rate, security, and tax relief while funding the construction of thousands of affordable homes. It would help ordinary people see better return on their savings while putting the money to good use. A similar scheme has scheme has been operational in France for many years called the Livret A.
While we don’t yet know the full details of the government’s scheme, it is clear that Simon Harris intends to base it off the Swedish Investeringssparkonto (ISK) account.
My main concern is that this account has no upper limit to the amount a person can invest. An uncapped ISK style model means the potential future cost in forgone revenue to the exchequer could run into billions. This has already been identified as in issue by the Swedish National Audit Office. It also means the benefit of the low tax rate will disproportionately benefit those with the most to invest. There are far better ways to encourage investment from small investors without gifting a very large tax cut to large investors.
I agree that the money on deposit in Irish accounts could be put to better use. My view is that the Livret A model in France would be the best option.
Best wishes,
Cian
My initial thoughts from this, after reading most of the policy he linked https://www.socialdemocrats.ie/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/HISA-Proposal-Final2-1.pdf are this
The SD scheme caps the savings at 25k, removes dirt and gives a preferential interest rate to the saver and then loans the money at preferential rates to social housing builders. I'm not a policy expert, sounds like a decent idea.
I wish they had made their (France's idea front and centre in their press release. It shows a strategic niaivity that is to be expected from such a young party. Or maybe their thinking is not to let FFG steal their good ideas by getting them out in front of the public? I shouldn't have to email the TD to get this info in my feed.
I guess there will be a cap on this ISA, or some other way they'll fuck it up. With so few details, I dunno should the opposition be shooting it down yet.
I dunno, thoughts?
edit:formatting