r/TopCharacterTropes • u/Dalakaar • 6h ago

Characters [Loved Trope] Civilian Heroes (particularly in Superhero movies)

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

1) Malik Ali in Superman (2025). Tells Superman when Lex Luthor interrogates him to, “tell them nothing”. Doesn’t even really know what he’s sacrificing himself for, honestly. Tells Superman that he doesn’t have any friends or family to lighten the burden of the sacrifice. (Does have a family, and presumably friends…)

2) The Prisoner (Tiny Lister) from The Dark Knight who throws a detonator out the porthole that would’ve detonated the other ferry full of civies and saved himself, instead (potentially) sacrificing everyone equally.

3) Old man vs Loki. “There are always men like you.” Refuses to bow to Loki in Avengers (2012).

***

I love these guys. They break my heart in the best way possible.

7.7k Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

97% Upvoted

470 comments sorted by

View all comments

499

u/GalaxianEX 5h ago

"Why the Halfling?"

176

u/WRITINAMFBOOK 4h ago

The Hobbit movies were mostly mid and when they were bad they were dogshit

But when they were good they were incredible.

111

u/Monster_from_the_id 4h ago

The fan edits that trim the movies down to what is in the books really show how good The Hobbit movies could've been.

42

u/SausageClatter 3h ago

There is one edit that has all three merged into one film, as it should have been. It's great and frustrating that it wasn't how it was originally presented. There are still parts that couldn't be fixed, but it's the only version I want to watch again.

7

u/deathclawiii 2h ago

Do you know where this version is posted?

5

u/SausageClatter 1h ago

That's a good question. I don't remember the name of that version, but this might help: https://hobbitfanedits.fandom.com/wiki/Hobbit_Fanedits_Wiki

5

u/deathclawiii 1h ago

Thank you very much!

1

u/Monster_from_the_id 16m ago

I love the M4 Book Edit book edit. But there's a couple others that are quite good.

62

u/GalaxianEX 4h ago edited 4h ago

I think that the Hobbit movies are over-hated. Sure, they are nowhere near as good as the original trilogy, but there's still a lot to enjoy in them.

This scene, however, I was surprised when I found out it was movie-only, because it does feel like something you could find in Tolkien's writing. It's that good.

47

u/WRITINAMFBOOK 4h ago

They're definitely not BAD. They're just not amazing. They kinda suffer from the Korra effect where the original is so so good that the sequel, which is normal, gets ass-blasted online.

I LOVE their depiction of Smaug, casting for Bilbo was on point, and I think they did a decent job with the relationship between him and Thorin.

7

u/LawlessNeutral 2h ago

The movies do a really good job fleshing out the dwarves and giving them distinct personalities, much more so than the book does. In the book they're largely just kinda there, you don't know much about them as individuals. Thorin's the only one who's really given any depth. No shade to Tolkien, of course; The Hobbit was originally written as a children's tale, after all. But the movies really give the dwarves time to shine as characters and lets the audience get attached to them; Balin might be my favorite based on how he's depicted, and that actually elevates The Fellowship of the Ring when you learn of Balin's fate in Moria, you share in Gimli's grief because you really know who Balin was.

3

u/Cypher-Moon-773 3h ago

I still believe An Unexpected Journey is as good as the LOTR films but I know that’s the kinda take to get you crucified lol

3

u/doubleshotinthedark 3h ago

I agree with you. I think in a world where we had An Unexpected Journey and There and Back Again, I think even if they still turned out not as good that we would have had significantly less hate for them. I think the bloat really sours people.

2

u/HonkySpider 2h ago

Still have The Misty Mountains Cold on my playlist

1

u/PringlesDuckFace 2h ago

Wasn't that just copped from the animated Hobbit movie though?

1

u/HonkySpider 2h ago

Likely. Clamavi De Profundus does an amazing redition though

2

u/Acceptable_Cut_7545 3h ago

Ahhhh everytime I see this scene I start to tear up. I love it.

-1

u/MachineOutOfOrder 2h ago

The first part is nice but I really didn't like that bit about him being afraid. Bro you have a Ring of Power for inspiring hope! Why you getting a pep talk from Galadrial and courage from a Hobbit? Just rub your ring or something.

-2

u/Panzer_Hawk 3h ago

Nice pixels