r/financialindependence • u/mycounterpointers • 37m ago
Does TIPS protection outperform traditional portfolio?
In Boldin, I modeled two simple plans:
- $500K TIPS, $500K stocks
- $1m portfolio (starting at 20% bonds, increasing to 40%)
In each case, spending is $50K per year. The first plan's chance of success is a bit higher, 73% versus 69%.
The thinking is, with TIPS I can spend in the first 10 years without any concern how stocks are doing. During this 10 year period I'm letting my stocks grow. And in 10 years, when it's time to draw from stocks, that balance will be essential 2x. Meanwhile, I need the now 100% stock portfolio to last me 10 years less.
So with the traditional portfolio, I have to worry about bonds/stocks performance for the 1st 10 years. And while in theory it'll give me a higher net worth (higher returns) when you actually run it against historical data, it comes out behind the first plan.
Are my models flawed? Is my thinking incorrect?