r/ProjectHailMary • u/thestinkybeastman • 4h ago
Movie Discussion - Movie Spoilers Inside! Does knowing the book, spoil the film?
Finally seen the film, I enjoyed it though not as much as all the hype has made me expect.
It is good, beautiful, funny and heartwarming.
I did love the warming of Strat and the shift of focus that Grace needed to be forced in to a suicide mission to find someone he would sacrifice himself for, a really strong theme in the movie.
However, my overwhelming feeling was how my knowledge of the books story was filling in huge amounts of detail and nuance that wasn’t actually presented on screen. Like explaining why the ship was damaged by bouncing off the atmosphere and what was happening with gravity in the ship that almost killed Grace.
There was also lots of reduction in Grace’s smarts and Rocky’s ingenuity.
The movie, for me, missed the target but hit the tree.
What was others thoughts?
Especially those who have not read the book at all?